Jump directly to pizza review DAY 1: OCTOBER 1st:Pizza Hut (Valrico, FL) DAY 2: OCTOBER 2nd:Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza (Tampa, FL) DAY 3: OCTOBER 3rd:Papa John's (Valrico, FL) DAY 4: OCTOBER 4th:Hungry Howie's (Valrico, FL) DAY 5: OCTOBER 5th:Zigolini's Pizza Bar (New York, NY) DAY 6: OCTOBER 6th:Totale Pizza (New York, NY) DAY 7: OCTOBER 7th:Artichoke Basilles Pizzeria (New York, NY) DAY 8: OCTOBER 8th:San Marzano (New York, NY) DAY 9: OCTOBER 9th:Spunto Thin Crust Pizza (New York, NY) DAY 10: OCTOBER 10th:Louie & Ernie's Pizza (Bronx, NY) DAY 11: OCTOBER 11th:Bar (New Haven, CT) DAY 12: OCTOBER 12th:Eataly (New York, NY) DAY 13: OCTOBER 13th:Donatella (New York, NY) DAY 14: OCTOBER 14th:Dean's (New York, NY) DAY 15 OCTOBER 15th:Ovest Pizzoteca by Luzzo (New York, NY) DAY 16: OCTOBER 16th:Pizza Moto (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 17: OCTOBER 17th:South Brooklyn Pizza (New York, NY) DAY 18: OCTOBER 18th:99¢ Fresh Pizza (New York, NY) DAY 19: OCTOBER 19th:Luigi's Pizza (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 20: OCTOBER 20th:Grimaldi's (Hoboken, NJ) DAY 21: OCTOBER 21st:Krispy Pizza (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 22: OCTOBER 22nd:Saraghina Restaurant (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 23: OCTOBER 23rd:Rose & Joe's Italian Bakery (Astoria, NY) DAY 24: OCTOBER 24th:Bella Via Restaurant (Long Island City, NY) DAY 25: OCTOBER 25th:Saluggi's Pizza (New York, NY) DAY 26: OCTOBER 26th:Toby's Public House (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 27: OCTOBER 27th:Paulie Gee's (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 28: OCTOBER 28th:Mariella Pizza (New York, NY) DAY 29: OCTOBER 29th:Free Suprema @the Magnet (New York, NY) DAY 30: OCTOBER 30th:Mario's Restaurant (Bronx, NY) DAY 31: OCTOBER 31st:Scott's Pizza Tours (New York, NY) DAY 31b: OCTOBER 31st:Totonno's (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 31c: OCTOBER 31st:J&V Pizzeria (Brooklyn, NY) DAY 31d: OCTOBER 31st:Sam's Restaurant (Brooklyn, NY)

Pizza Month 2010 Pizza Month 2009 Pizza Month 2008 Pizza Month 2007 Pizza Month 2006 Pizza Month 2005 Pizza Month 2004 Pizza Month 2003 Pizza Month 2002 Slicey Award Ceremony to be announced.... DAY 1: OCTOBER 1st Pizza Hut 3220 Lithia Pinecrest Rd. #101 Valrico, FL (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   2.5/5   AMBIENCE: 2.5/3 TASTE: 4/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 9/18 = 0.5 x 5 = 2.5 DAY 2: OCTOBER 2nd Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza 203 East Twiggs Street Tampa, FL (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   3/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 11/18 = 0.611 x 5 = 3.055 DAY 3: OCTOBER 3rd Papa John's 3517 Bell Shoals Road Valrico, FL (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4/5   AMBIENCE: 2.5/3 TASTE: 6.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 13/18 = 0.722 x 5 = 3.61 DAY 4: OCTOBER 4th Hungry Howie's 2501 State Road 60 E Valrico, FL (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 7.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 15.5/18 = 0.861 x 5 = 4.305 DAY 5: OCTOBER 5th Zigolini's Pizza Bar 675 9th Avenue New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   3.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 8/10 SERVICE: 3/3 17.5/21 = 0.833 x 5 = 4.165 DAY 6: OCTOBER 6th Totale Pizza 36 St. Marks Pl New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 7.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 15.5/18 = 0.861 x 5 = 4.305 DAY 7: OCTOBER 7th Artichoke Basilles Pizzeria 114 10th Ave New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4/5   AMBIENCE: 2.5/3 TASTE: 8/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 14.5/18 = 0.806 x 5 = 4.03 DAY 8: OCTOBER 8th San Marzano 71 Clinton Street New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   2.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 5/10 SERVICE: 3/3 13.5/21 = 0.643 x 5 = 3.215 DAY 9: OCTOBER 9th Spunto Thin Crust Pizza 65 Carmine Street New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   2.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 7/10 SERVICE: 3/3 15.5/21 = 0.738 x 5 = 3.69 DAY 10: OCTOBER 10th Louie & Ernie's Pizza 1300 Crosby Avenue Bronx, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 8/10 SERVICE: 3/3 18.5/21 = 0.881 x 5 = 4.405 DAY 11: OCTOBER 11th Bar 254 Crown St. New Haven, CT (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 8.5/10 SERVICE: 3/3 19/21 = 0.905 x 5 = 4.525 DAY 12: OCTOBER 12th Eataly 200 5th Ave New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   2/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 8/10 SERVICE: 3/3 16/21 = 0.762 x 5 = 3.81 DAY 13: OCTOBER 13th Donatella 184 8th Ave New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 9/10 SERVICE: 3/3 19.5/21 = 0.929 x 5 = 4.645 DAY 14: OCTOBER 14th Dean's 801 2nd Ave New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 9/10 SERVICE: 3/3 19.5/21 = 0.929 x 5 = 4.645 DAY 15 OCTOBER 15th Ovest Pizzoteca by Luzzo 513 West 27th Street New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 9/10 SERVICE: 3/3 19.5/21 = 0.929 x 5 = 4.645 DAY 16: OCTOBER 16th Pizza Moto 176 Lafayette Ave Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 2/3 TASTE: 8.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 15/18 = 0.833 x 5 = 4.165 DAY 17: OCTOBER 17th South Brooklyn Pizza 122 1st Avenue New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4/5   AMBIENCE: 2.5/3 TASTE: 7.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 14/18 = 0.778 x 5 = 3.89 DAY 18: OCTOBER 18th 99¢ Fresh Pizza 360 W. 42nd St New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   5/5   AMBIENCE: .5/3 TASTE: 3/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 8.5/18 = 0.472 x 5 = 2.36 DAY 19: OCTOBER 19th Luigi's Pizza 686 5th Ave Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   5/5   AMBIENCE: 2/3 TASTE: 7.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 14.5/18 = 0.806 x 5 = 4.03 DAY 20: OCTOBER 20th Grimaldi's 411 Washington St. Hoboken, NJ (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 8.5/10 SERVICE: 3/3 19/21 = 0.905 x 5 = 4.525 DAY 21: OCTOBER 21st Krispy Pizza 7112 13th Ave Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 7/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 14/18 = 0.778 x 5 = 3.89 DAY 22: OCTOBER 22nd Saraghina Restaurant 435 Halsey Street Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   /5   AMBIENCE: /3 TASTE: /10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 Not Applicable DAY 23: OCTOBER 23rd Rose & Joe's Italian Bakery 2240 31st Street Astoria, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   5/5   AMBIENCE: 2/3 TASTE: 8.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 15.5/18 = 0.861 x 5 = 4.305 DAY 24: OCTOBER 24th Bella Via Restaurant 47-46 Vernon Boulevard Long Island City, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 9/10 SERVICE: 3/3 19.5/21 = 0.929 x 5 = 4.645 DAY 25: OCTOBER 25th Saluggi's Pizza 325 Church Street New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   3.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 7/10 SERVICE: 3/3 16.5/21 = 0.786 x 5 = 3.93 DAY 26: OCTOBER 26th Toby's Public House 686 6th Avenue Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 9.5/10 SERVICE: 3/3 20/21 = 0.952 x 5 = 4.76 DAY 27: OCTOBER 27th Paulie Gee's 60 Greenpoint Avenue Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 9.5/10 SERVICE: 3/3 20/21 = 0.952 x 5 = 4.76 DAY 28: OCTOBER 28th Mariella Pizza 960 8th Avenue New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   3.5/5   AMBIENCE: 2.5/3 TASTE: 6.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 12.5/18 = 0.694 x 5 = 3.47 DAY 29: OCTOBER 29th Free Suprema @the Magnet 254 West 29th St New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   /5   AMBIENCE: /3 TASTE: /10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 Not Applicable DAY 30: OCTOBER 30th Mario's Restaurant 2342 Arthur Ave Bronx, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   3/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 8/10 SERVICE: 3/3 17/21 = 0.81 x 5 = 4.05 DAY 31: OCTOBER 31st Scott's Pizza Tours 53 Spring St New York, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   /5   AMBIENCE: /3 TASTE: /10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 Not Applicable DAY 31b: OCTOBER 31st Totonno's 1524 Neptune Ave Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 10/10 SERVICE: 3/3 21/21 = 1 x 5 = 5 DAY 31c: OCTOBER 31st J&V Pizzeria 6322 18th Ave Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   4/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 7.5/10 SERVICE: N/A 0/0 14.5/18 = 0.806 x 5 = 4.03 DAY 31d: OCTOBER 31st Sam's Restaurant 238 Court Street Brooklyn, NY (click to open full review and video clip) OVERALL: VALUE:   3.5/5   AMBIENCE: 3/3 TASTE: 8/10 SERVICE: 3/3 17.5/21 = 0.833 x 5 = 4.165